Apple Cinnamon Jelly

A few weeks ago we had a spontaneous trip back to my home state California! While we were there we decided why not visit Knott’s Berry Farm and let our little guy get to know a few new characters. He’s just now getting into the Charlie Brown cartoons and I just knew he would go crazy to see the life sized version.

And I admit I had a little tiny bit of a selfish reason to visit. They have a pastry shop attached to the park with the most amazing boysenberry pie! I was looking forward to a giant slice and bringing home a jar of their apple cinnamon jelly. The pie was delicious, but I was left super disappointed when I found out that they no longer carried the jelly I was searching for at the park.

I decided that I just couldn’t “order it offline” and quickly got to work creating my own version of this sweet treat!


5 lbs of apples
4 cinnamon sticks
1 tablespoon whole cloves
2 cups water
7 cups sugar
1 package pectin

The night before you are ready to can your jelly: Quarter your apples. You want the peel, core, and all. Place them in a slow cooker with the cinnamon sticks, cloves, and water. Turn it on low and let that baby cook for 10 to 12 hours.

Place a strainer over a large bowl in the sink. Lay cheesecloth on top of your strainer and slowly pour your apple mixture into the straining device. Gently press the cloth with a large spoon getting as much juice out of your apples as you possibly can ( I did this in several batches).

You should get about 7 cups of juice from this, but just in case… you can add a little bit of apple juice if you need to top things off. Place your 7 cups of juice into the large pot with the pectin. Bring to a rapid boil.

Stir in the sugar and cook for an additional two minutes. Place into your sterilized jars and follow proper canning instructions.


This jelly is so so so so good. It is like apple pie in jelly form. My son, who is a giant jelly snob, was eating this up by the spoonful. Until I caught him that is. . . He now goes around telling everyone that “we DON’T eat jelly from the jar!”


Hopefully my brother isn’t reading this post. I am pretty sure he is the one that turned me onto this amazing spread, and it is very possible some of this (with fresh baked bread) will be their Christmas treat! And maybe a few of my friends… But I’m PRETTY sure most people just come here for the photos! ;0)


  1. says

    Ohmygosh your little boy is so cute!!! That’s funny that he’s been sharing his new found knowledge with others :) This looks SO good and would make an AWESOME friend/neighbor gift! I’ll have to keep that in mind next year! Pinning!

    • Jesseca says

      I’ve made this several times with different types of apples and it always turns out great. Our favorite are with red delicious.

  2. Sandra semonski says

    I made this before Christmas , it didn’t set up, I was sadly disappointed ! It tasted good but ended up throwing it out , waste of time & money ……. : (

    • Jesseca says

      If you had problems with the jelly setting you might need to add a minute or two to the cook time. We made a second batch for the holidays and it turned out great. Everyone always asks for an extra jar.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>