Skip to Content

The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe

The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe – and only one you will want to make again! French bread, garlic butter, and medium cheddar gives you the perfect melted cheese sandwich! 

The best ever grilled cheese sandwich

My nine year old came up with this recipe. His genius idea to replace the butter with a garlic butter was mind blowing.

Why in the world have I never thought to do this??

He was so casual about his idea too. I think it went something like… “We should try garlic butter grilled cheese.” followed by a shoulder shrug.

From that day forward this is the only grilled cheese recipe we have made.

It is so simple and yet so tasty and also happens to be our go-to for busy weeknights. To make it more filling, you can add your favorite protein, but it is delicious all on its own.

Elevated Cheese Sandwich Recipe

How to make the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich recipe

Since this recipe calls for minimal ingredients, it is important that you pick quality products. We like to use French bread and a good medium cheddar cheese. Homemade garlic butter is key to the flavor explosion. Make sure you check out my recipe before you get started.

How to make a grilled cheese sandwich on the stove:

  1. Spread soft butter on one side of two pieces of bread.
  2. Layer your buttered bread (butter side out) with cheese slices sandwiched in the middle.
  3. Grill 2 minutes on each side in a heated pan until golden brown.

How to make garlic butter:

You will want to head over to my recipe for the exact measurements, but this garlic butter is so delicious. Great with grilled cheese, garlic toast, fish, or steak. Give it a try and you will not be disappointed.

  1. Place butter, minced garlic, Parmesan cheese, garlic powder, Italian seasoning, and ground pepper in a large bowl.
  2. Mix together until smooth.

Alternatively, you could use a store bought garlic spread. We like the added cheese in our homemade version. It gives this grilled cheese sandwich a crispy cheese crust that is divine.

Building the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich

What cheese is best for a grilled cheese sandwich?

This question is best answered by my child. He is a self proclaimed cheese connoisseur. His top picks are:

  • American
  • Mild Cheddar
  • Pepper Jack

You also want to consider any toppings you will be adding. Turkey pairs well with pepper jack or Swiss, while ham is more of a cheddar. Go ahead and mix and match your cheese varieties too. Place a slice of pepper jack with cheddar. That’s my favorite.

What bread is best for a grilled cheese?

It is extremely difficult to find a bread that is not good as a grilled cheese sandwich. Some of our go-to flavors are sour dough, multigrain, classic white bread, or even English muffins. The top pick has to be fresh sliced french bread. Spread with garlic butter and grilled to a beautiful golden brown – There is nothing quite like it.

The best ever grilled cheese sandwich recipe

A few serving ideas:

  • Along side tomato soup
  • With a handful of chips
  • Or a light salad

No matter what you decide to serve this incredible recipe with, one thing is for sure. The entire family will love it.

How to make the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich

Like this recipe? You will love my:

The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe

The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe

Yield: 2 sandwiches
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 10 minutes

The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe - and only one you will want to make again! French bread, garlic butter, and medium cheddar gives you the perfect melted cheese sandwich! 

Ingredients

  • 4 slices French bread*
  • 3 tablespoons garlic butter
  • 6 slices medium cheddar cheese

Instructions

  1. Spread 1/2 of a tablespoon onto one side of each of your bread slices. 
  2. Build your sandwich. Layer bread slice (butter side down), three slices of cheese, and bread slice (butter side up). Repeat with the remaining bread and cheese.
  3. Heat a skillet over medium heat. Place one of your sandwiches onto the heated surface. Cook 2 minutes on each side, or until golden brown and the cheese is melted. 
  4. Repeat with the second sandwich. 

Notes

Use any bread or cheese variety with this recipe. 

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Pin for later:
The BEST Grilled Cheese Recipe - and only one you will want to make again! French bread, garlic butter, and medium cheddar gives you the perfect melted cheese sandwich! 

Still hungry? Follow One Sweet Appetite on FacebookInstagram and Pinterest for more great recipe ideas!

Previous
Easy Garlic Butter Recipe
Next
The BEST and Easiest Homemade Meatball Recipe

Candace

Monday 25th of February 2019

This is such a simple concept but I never thought to use garlic butter. We made this and added ham and turkey. It made a tasty dinner. Next time I think I will add some vegetables. Boyfriend said it was the best grilled cheese he has ever had.

Jesseca

Monday 25th of February 2019

Glad you liked it. I love the idea of adding vegetables.

shares