Homemade Wendy’s Frosty

Sharing is caring!

This Wendy’s frosty recipe is almost better than the original! You only need three ingredients- Chocolate milk, sweetened condensed milk, and Cool Whip!

Recipe Features

• 3-Ingredient Dessert– You only need three simple ingredients to make this delicious chocolate frosty.
• Perfect Beginner Dessert Recipe
• Best Copycat Chocolate Frosty! This seriously tastes just as good, if not better, than the frosty you get from Wendy’s.

We are obsessed with dipping fries into Wendy’s magic chocolate frosty. The combination of salty and sweet is irresistible and dreamy. But the closest restaurant is far enough away that we don’t get to indulge as much as we would like. So it only made sense we would learn to make our own!

This Wendy’s homemade frosty has been a work in progress for a few weeks. I browsed their website to get a basic idea of what was inside and continually saw there are three ingredients people claim make the BEST. I rolled up my sleeves and got to work. Turns out, they were right! But finding that perfect proportion was tricky.

I’m glad to report that after a few misses we finally found the way to make the very best chocolate frosty!

Wendy’s Chocolate Frosty Ingredients

The three frosty ingredients you will need are fairly basic. All together I spend less than $6 and had enough for 8 generous servings! So head to the grocery store and pick up:

• Chocolate Milk- Alternatively, you could make your own using Hershey’s syrup or Nesquick.
• Sweetened Condensed Milk
• Cool Whip- The original flavor.

That’s it! Crazy, right?

Is Wendy’s Frosty A Milkshake

Technically, no. Well, for this recipe anyway. Wendy’s frosty falls right in between a milkshake and soft serve. As their website states, “The frosty is thick enough to use a spoon, smooth enough to use a straw, and perfect when enjoyed on the end of a fry.”

How To Make Wendy’s Chocolate Frosty Recipe

So I’ve talked you into giving this homemade frosty recipe a try, now what? Well, we have two options. You can make this using an ice cream maker, which I highly recommend, or you can try the freeze and whisk method that I use for sorbet. I’ll break down both for you.

For an Ice Cream Maker:

1. Combine the ingredients into a blender. Pulse until smooth.
2. Pour into a prepared ice cream maker and follow the manufacture’s instructions for freezing, checking frequently for your desired consistency.
3. Ours took roughly 20 minutes to get to frosty texture.
4. Serve!

Freeze and Mix Version:

1. Combine the ingredients into a blender. Pulse until smooth.
2. Pour the mixture into an airtight container and place into the freezer.
3. Whisk every 20 minutes for one to two hours, or until you reach the perfect frosty consistency.

Copycat Frosty Tips

• You can make the “batter” in advance and have it ready to go whenever you are. We keep it stored in a sealed container, unfrozen, for up to one week.
• Alternatively, you could make and freeze a large batch and keep it stored for up to 3 weeks.
• No need to buy chocolate milk to make this wendy’s milkshake. You can easily substitute regular milk with a few spoonfuls of Nesquick or Hershey’s syrup.
• Want a large batch? Double the ingredients and you’ll have enough for 16 servings!

Can You Put A Frosty In The Freezer?

The big question is can you keep Wendy’s frosty recipe in the freezer? Yep. You definitely can.

Make your frosty as directed all the way through freezing. Transfer to an airtight container, I recommend reusable ice cream containers, and keep stored for up to 3 weeks. Storing properly will extend the life of your ice cream and keep it from accumulating any odd smells or freezer burn.

When you are ready to eat let it sit at room temperature for about 20 minutes. This should help it soften enough to dish out servings. Although, I have to admit, ours doesn’t last long before we eat it all!

More Frozen Treats

• Orange Dreamsicle
• How to Make No-Churn Ice Cream
• Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
• Southern Banana Pudding Ice Cream
• Homemade Orange Sherbet Ice Cream
• Mixed Berry Sorbet
• Slow Melting Jell-O Popsicles
• Fresh Strawberry Milkshake
• Key Lime Ice Cream
• Birthday Cake Ice Cream

More Copycat Recipes

• Starbucks Strawberry Frappuccino Recipe
• Harry Potter Frozen Butterbeer
• Copycat Chick-Fil-A Frosted Lemonade
• Homemade Fudge Pops
• Buffalo Wild Wings Asian Zing Sauce Recipe
• Copycat Chili’s Queso
• Sizzler Malibu Chicken

Still hungry? Follow One Sweet Appetite on Facebook, Instagram and Pinterest for more great recipe ideas!